Contents
Download PDF
pdf Download XML
181 Views
2 Downloads
Share this article
Research Article | Volume 23 Issue: 3 (July-Sep, 2024) | Pages 1 - 5
Clinical course and outcome of Covid 19 in vaccinated high-risk individuals admitted in a tertiary care institution in Palakkad
 ,
1
Assistant Professor Dept. of General Medicine Govt. Medical College (IIMS) Palakkad, kerala, India
2
Assistant Professor Department of General Medicine Government Medical College Palakkad, kerala, India
Under a Creative Commons license
Open Access
Received
July 5, 2024
Revised
July 20, 2024
Accepted
Aug. 20, 2024
Published
Sept. 9, 2024
Abstract

Background: With the fast-track development of vaccines worldwide, the severity and hospitalisations due to covid 19 has come down and vaccinated people are getting the disease in a milder form than unvaccinated people. Here in our study, we are focussing on the breakthrough infections in high-risk population who are vaccinated twice with any of the covid vaccines as per present national protocols. Though all the current vaccines available in the world do not confer 100 percent protection against the disease, they do prevent the development of very severe disease and decreases mortality compared to unvaccinated people. This study is to find out the clinical severity based on clinical, biochemical and other inflammatory markers and radiological features in the above-mentioned population. This study provided information about the difference in outcome of covid 19 in different comorbid conditions. Objective: To assess the severity of Covid 19 affected in high-risk groups who are vaccinated with two doses of any vaccine against Covid 19 based on the clinical, laboratory and radiological parameters. Methods: Observational cohort study, Data required for the study is procured from the covid 19 patients admitted in isolation wards and intensive care units in District Hospital Palakkad. The medical records of those patients were also used as the sources of information required for the study during 2021. Results In our study 76.5% of patients were above 60years old and only 3.9% are below 40 years. Regarding gender66.7% were males. Diabetes mellitus is the most common comorbidity ie 58.82% followed by Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease 21.57% and Coronary artery disease 17.65%.Out of 51 participants,43 had taken covishield which comes to 84.31%.Clinically 19.6% had tachycardia ,21.57% had elevated systolic blood pressure of over 140mmHg whereas 13.8% had diastolic BP above 90mmHg.Respiratory rate of above 20 per minute was found in 51% ,13.7% had SPO2 >94% in room air.41.17% required nasal oxygen via prongs or facemask ,19.6% required Non invasive ventilation. Of the biochemical and hematopathological parameters studied 70.6% had D Dimer more than 500,58.8% had absolute neutrophil count less than 8000 and.88.2% had NLR over 3. Imaging studies showed 68.63% with an abnormal chest X ray.31 people had their HRCT thorax done out of which 45.16% had moderate lung involvement and 35.46% had severe lung involvement. Regarding the outcome 80.39% were discharged in a clinically stable condition and only 10 patients succumbed to their illness. Interpretation and conclusions Break through covid19 infection in high-risk population is associated with a mortality rate of 20% which is significantly higher than those without comorbidity. The risk of developing severe disease is also more in those groups compared to general population. Diabetes mellitus is the most important and common risk factor associated with poor outcome. ARDS is the most common cause of mortality in covid 19 which is aggravated by the coexistence of comorbidities.

Keywords
INTRODUCTION

The global pandemic Covid 19 has created immense havoc. The first case of Covid 19 in India was reported in kerala in January 2020.The Palakkad district in Kerala had been going through the struggling phase of tackling this disease since March 2020.Covid 19 is a viral infection caused by corona virus,an RNA virus.Corona viruses in humans mainly causes respiratory infection.In most of the cases it results in minor or self limiting illness in the form of fever,cough,sorethroat,sneezing etc similar to other viral respiratory illnesses.But in some patients,especially high risk individuals,the disease is not limited to upper respiratory tract and they develop viral pneumonia,ARDS like picture or in severe cases respiratory failure and death.Some patients recovering from the illness have fibrosis and scarring as long term sequelae which will cause serious impairment in their quality of living.In India,the first vaccines approved for use were COVISHIELD-a genetically engineered adenoviral vector vaccine and COVAXIN-inactivated coronavirus vaccine.Here in our study,we are focussing on breakthrough infections in high risk population who are completely vaccinated with the above vaccines as per present national protocols.The serum institute of India could manufacture covishield which is the version of oxford Astrazeneca which has 76% efficacy after two doses.Genetic studies have shown that covishield is effective against different variants of SARS- CoV -2 including the delta strain which caused severe disease.Covaxin is developed by Bharat Biotech in collaboration with ICMR-NIV Pune.This is an inactivated virus based COVID 19 vaccine.The vaccine is reported to be 64% effective against asymptomatic cases,93% effective against symptomatic cases and 65% effective against Delta variant.Observational studies conducted by Lancet consistently demonstrated that vaccinations are extremely effective against severe illness including those caused by all major viral strains.Only a few studies have been conducted on breakthrough infections in high risk population.A similar study conducted by Lancet concluded that vaccination is effective against severe disease in those with comorbidities.Its highlighted in another study that even if the antibody levels in vaccinated people decline overtime the effectiveness against severe illness will persist.This means that the protection provided by vaccines is not only mediated by antibody but also by memory responses and cell mediated immunity.It is critical to vaccinate all individuals to combat the disease. A study on the clinical course and outcome of confirmed cases of vaccinated Covid 19 in high-risk population will provide a clear idea about the disease-host interplay in vaccinated people. This study is to find out the disease severity based on clinical, biochemical and radiological features in the above-mentioned population. This study will help in categorising and characterising the disease severity in high risk vaccinated people and help in providing an early assessment and better clinical care for them.

 

Objective: To assess the severity of Covid 19 affected in high-risk groups who are vaccinated with two doses of any vaccine against Covid 19 based on the clinical, laboratory and radiological parameters.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study was conducted at District Hospital Palakkad where the clinical department of Government Medical College Palakkad has been functioning.

  • Eligibility criteria: patients admitted to covid hospital who are high risk individuals and has taken two doses of any vaccine against Covid 19 .
  • Criteria for high-risk category: age above 60years, diabetes mellitus, obesity, chronic kidney disease, chronic respiratory illness, malignancy, sickle cell anemia, organ transplant recipient, chronic liver disease, cardiac failure, coronary artery disease, systemic hypertension, old cerebrovascular accident, immunocompromised state and any other significant comorbidity which can alter the outcome of COVID
  • Inclusion criteria: Patients admitted and treated completely from District Hospital Palakkad.
  • Exclusion criteria: Pregnant patients and those adults with past history of COVID 19, those who were not willing to be included are excluded from the study

 

Variables:

Age, sex, comorbid illness, Respiratory rate, oxygen saturation, CRP, D Dimer, Neutrophil Lymphocyte Ratio, Absolute Neutrophil Count, HRCT scoring or chest X ray findings (whichever is available), requirement of oxygenation and/or ventilator support, disease outcome.

 

The source of data is the patient himself/herself and medical records.

 

Appropriate statistical tests are used during the study.

Data sources: patient, medical records No bias encountered Study sample size is 51 .

All the patients admitted and completed treatment during the period of study satisfying the eligibility and inclusion criteria are included in the study.

 

Statistical methods: Quantitative variables are expressed as mean with standard deviation.

 

Qualitative variables are expressed as percentage. The first step was identification of eligible cases, second was assessing the clinical, laboratory and radiological parameters and the third was to assess the outcome of the disease.

RESULTS

In our study more than 70% of patients were above 60years of age with male sex predeliction.CRP was elevated in 80% of patients and D Dimer was elevated in 70% of patients.57% of patients were of category B and 43% developed pneumonia, hence included under category C .Out of category C patients, 29% had moderate disease and 14% had severe disease.20% of patients required ventilator support of which 95% were under non invasive ventilation. Out of 51 patients only single patient was put on mechanical ventilation and he expired.

 

Table 1 sociodemography

Age(years)

No. of patients

Percentage

30-40

2

3.9

40-50

3

5.9

50-60

7

13.7

>60

39

76.5

Sex

Male

34

66.7

Female

17

33.3

Total

51

100

 

Table 2Comorbidities

Comorbidities

No. of patients

Percentage (n=51)

CAD

9

17.65

SHT

3

5.88

DM

30

58.82

COPAD/BA

11

21.57

CVA

5

9.80

CKD/AKI/FSGS

7

13.72

Others

13

25.49

NIL

4

7.84

 

Table 3 Vaccine

Vaccine

No. of patients

Percentage

Covishield

43

84.31

Covaxin

8

15.69

Total

51

 

 

Table 4 physical parameters

Pulse rate(bpm)

No. of patients

Percentage

60-100

41

80.39

>100

10

19.6

SBP(mmHg)

100-140

40

78.43

>140

11

21.57

DBP(mmHg)

60-90

44

86.27

>90

7

13.8

 

Respiration rate(per minute)

 

 

<20

25

49

 

 

>20

26

51

 

           

 

Table 5 according to Oxygen saturation

SPO2

No. of patients

Percentage

<90%

7

13.7

90-94%

15

29.4

>94%

29

56.9

Total

51

 

 

Table 6 mode of ventilation

Mode of ventilation

No. of patients

Percentage

Not required

19

37.25

Nasal oxygen

21

41.17

NIV/CPAP

10

19.6

Mechanical Ventilation

1

0.0196

 

Table 7 according to CRP and d - dimer

CRP

No. of Patients

Percentage

<10

10

19.6

>10

41

80.4

D Dimer

<500

15

29.4

>500

36

70.6

Total

51

 

 

Table 8 According to hematological parameters

Absolute Neutrophil Count

No. of patients

Percentage

≤8000

30

58.8

>8000

21

41.2

Neutrophil Lymphocyte Ratio

 

≤3

6

11.8

 

>3

45

88.2

 

           

 

Table 9 Radiological investigations

Chest X ray

No. of patients

Percentage

Normal

16

31.37

Abnormal

35

68.63

HRCT thorax

Mild

6

19.36

Moderate

14

45.16

Severe

11

35.48

 

Table 10 outcome

Outcome

No. of patients

Percentage

Died

10

19.61

Discharged

41

80.39

Total

51

 

DISCUSSION

In the present study the patients belonging to age group 32-85 years were included. Covid 19 always showed male sex predeliction irrespective of genotype. Most common comorbid illness which needed hospital admission was diabetes mellitus followed by chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Covishield is the vaccine received by 84% of patients in our study and other studies have shown that it is 99% effective in preventing complications in general population. The presence of tachycardia and tachypnoea indicates disease progression in covid19.Bloodpressure has no significant role in predicting the outcome of the disease. The outcome of mechanical ventilation is worse in covid 19.CRP as an inflammatory marker directly correlated with disease progression. D Dimer is a marker of both inflammation and risk of thrombotic complications. It was markedly elevated in those patients needed ICU admission. A low absolute neutrophil count and high neutrophil lymphocyte ratio were found in those with moderate to severe disease. Chest X ray in available cases showed bilateral lower zone non homogenous opacities. Based on HRCT chest scoring out of 25, 30% had severe disease at the time of admission. Severe disease at the time of admission showed a very poor outcome compared to those who progress to severe disease after hospitalisation. This study revealed that diabetes mellitus, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic kidney disease are the most important risk factors determining severe disease with high risk for mortality. Other comorbidities found in our patients include obesity, hypothyroidism, peripheral vascular disease, Parkinson plus and psychiatric illness. The study concluded that covishield provides 57% protection against severe disease and 80% protection against mortality in high risk group of individuals.

 

Acknowledgement:  Nil

Conflicts of interest: Nil

REFERENCES
  1. Hacisuleyman, Ezgi, Caryn Hale, Yuhki Saito, Nathalie E. Blachere, et al. "Vaccine Breakthrough Infections with SARS-CoV-2 Variants." New England Journal of Medicine, 21 Apr. 2021, doi:10.1056/NEJMoa2105000.
  2. Bergwerk, Moriah, et al. "Covid-19 Breakthrough Infections in Vaccinated Health Care Workers." New England Journal of Medicine, 2021, doi:10.1056/NEJMoa2110475.
  3. Stephenson, J. "Covid-19 Vaccinations in Nursing Home Residents and Staff Give Robust Protection, Though Breakthrough Infections Still Possible." JAMA Health Forum, 2021, doi:10.1001/jamahealthforum.2021.0170.
  4. Tyagi, K., Ghosh, A., Nair, D., et al. "Breakthrough COVID-19 Infections After Vaccinations in Healthcare and Other Workers in a Chronic Care Medical Facility in New Delhi, India." Diabetes & Metabolic Syndrome: Clinical Research & Reviews, May-Jun. 2021, doi:10.1016/j.dsx.2021.01.003.
  5. Schmidt, A. L., Labaki, C., et al. "Covid-19 Vaccination and Breakthrough Infections in Patients with Cancer." Annals of Oncology, Mar. 2022, doi:10.1016/j.annonc.2022.01.002.
  6. Dey, Rajib Kumar, Abdullah Isneen Hilmy, et al. "Covid-19 and Emergencies in Patients with Diabetes: Two Case Reports." Journal of Medical Case Reports, Feb. 2021, doi:10.1186/s13256-021-02785-4.
  7. Pakhchanian, Haig, Rahul Raiker, et al. "Outcomes of Covid-19 in CKD Patients." Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, May 2021, doi:10.2215/CJN.03530321.
Recommended Articles
Research Article
Actual issues of higher pharmaceutical education
Download PDF
Research Article
Immunogenic properties of viper (Vipera Lebetina) venom
...
Download PDF
Research Article
Technological methods of preparation of “Insanovin” tablet
Download PDF
Research Article
Study of lipids of some plants from the flora of Azerbaijan
Download PDF
Chat on WhatsApp
© Copyright None